What If Your Credit Score Determined Your Social Standing?

Imagine what it would be like if your credit score determined your social standing.

This is actually happening in China — it’s not just the stuff of dystopian science fiction anymore.

China is combining credit scoring, social media, and e-commerce incentives to reward people for obeying the government.

Phoenix Rising

Until very recently, China lacked the kind of payment infrastructure that industrialized nations have had in place for decades. It lacked credit scoring, like what the U.S. has had since 1989, when Fair Isaac first unveiled its FICO scores.

Essentially making up for lost time, China in recent years has embraced mobile commerce so aggressively that it has leapfrogged ahead of the rest of the world and is now considered the leader in mobile commerce.

The two main players in China’s mobile commerce, AliPay and WeChat, are “less like apps than entire ecosystems,” writes Mara Hvistendahl in Wired. 

AliPay’s ecosystem includes the world’s largest retailer, Alibaba — yes, it handles more transactions than even Amazon does and boasts 550 million active mobile users.

Credit Score Overdrive

The AliPay ecosystem includes Sesame Credit, an app developed in partnership with the Chinese government. It acts as a credit bureau — except that it measures creditworthiness not just based on people’s financial behavior but also their social activities.

A Sesame Credit score also reflects who someone is friends with and how they interact — this information is harvested from a social media component of the AliPay ecosystem.

One way or another Sesame Credit is assigning numerical values to the types of products and services a person purchases, who their friends are on social media and what they post about on online.

All a Game?

Sesame Credit’s parent company Ant Financial works in partnership with gaming company Tencent (which is also the corporate parent of the other big mobile commerce company WeChat).

Tencent infuses the credit scoring with gamification capabilities — this means taking something that already exists and infusing game-like mechanics to motivate participation, engagement, and loyalty.

The result literally rewards people for obeying the government.

Fortunately, as of this writing, Sesame Credit remains an opt-in system, meaning you have to sign up for it, but it’s scheduled to become mandatory in 2020.

No Unsubscribing

Between now and then, it’s possible there’s time for Sesame Credit to improve upon its scores before they become mandatory — but they already lack an ability to unsubscribe once you sign up for it.

Another problematic aspect: Once a Sesame Credit score drops, there can be a downward spiral of further declines that begins with losing incentives confined to those with high scores.

At a certain point, low scores have much graver consequences than simply being declined for loans, credit cards or jobs involving money handling (many American banks credit score job applicants).

You begin to lose privileges that reflect your level of trustworthiness. For instance, you are subjected to more thorough searches when you pass through Chinese customs. Eventually, if you score low enough, you may be declined for social security and even welfare.

That downward spriral  invokes scenarios from dystopian science fiction — like the episode of Black Mirror in which people’s social scores determine where they can live and work.

Privacy Issues

If anything, looking at China’s credit scoring system provides interesting contrasts with the privacy vulnerabilities of U.S. credit bureaus — which may have served as the original inspiration for the Wired article mentioned above.

Barely three months ago, Equifax announced that hackers exposed up to 143 million Americans’ credit files along with those of people in other countries. It remains unclear whether and to what extent the breach triggered any identity thefts among those affected so far.

Readers, how does learning about China’s credit scoring system make you feel about U.S. credit bureaus?

Join our newsletter

If you like Critical Financial, subscribe and get our latest content via email.

Powered by Seva

Share this post:

Recent Posts

Leave a Comment

*

May the 4th Be with You: Star Wars Swag on Amazon

May the 4th Be With You: Star Wars Day Swag

It began as the punniest holiday ever but quickly grew into an earnest (if somewhat random) celebration of the long-running (and still... more →
People count the money to buy a house in future success.

Avoiding Mortgage Scams: Don’t Fall for Unreasonable Promises

If it sounds too good to be true, it probably is. That’s sound advice for almost all aspects of life, including the search for... more →
Eat for free for a whole month via the meal kit companies discounts for new customers.

How To Get a Month of Free Food: 9 Meal Kit Companies Offering Discounts to New Customers

Play your cards right and you might be able to line up a month’s worth of free meals if you were to try out all nine of the meal... more →
Generate extra cashflow -- here are 97 ways.

96 Awesome Ways to Generate Extra Cashflow

Who doesn’t want more money nowadays? We’ve got you covered on that front. Here comes a long list of different ideas on... more →
Valentine's Day gifts that won't destroy your budget

Valentine’s Day Crafts Are Romantic Rescue from Crazy Inflation

Fall for the hype this week and you’re out an average of $143.56 for Valentine’s Day. Crafts and other do-it-yourself tactics... more →

Ultimate Guide to Bitcoin — FREE Ebook!

Have we got something for you: a free ebook about bitcoin! more →
Get a flu vaccine.

Why You Need To Get a Flu Vaccine Right Now

Flu vaccines aren’t just for the elderly  anymore. Here are 25 reasons you should go get vaccinated. more →
Financially successful

Acquire the Trait All Financially Successful People Have

Financially successful people tend to all have a lot of self-discipline. Improving your discipline in one area of your life often spills... more →

What’s the Best Free Recipe App?

The Apple Store and Google Play together offer more digital cookbooks than you probably have room for on your mobile device. So which... more →
New tax law might slow down housing market.

What Will the New Tax Law Do to the Housing Market?

The new tax law will have a profound impact on the housing market, although in ways that go beyond the deductibility of mortgage interest... more →

4 in 5 Households Will Get a Tax Cut in 2018

Four out of five U.S. households will get a tax cut as a result of the legislation that President Donald Trump signed into law today. more →
Will bitcoin reach $100,000?

When Will Bitcoin Reach $100,000?

Bitcoin has accelerated its pace of appreciation in recent months, and if the current levels between $15,000 and $19,000 make you itch... more →
The Dow Jones topped 24,000 -- now what?

The Dow Jones Crossed the 24,000 Threshold. Now What?

Stocks appear to be increasing in volatility, yet the markets closed on Monday, December 4 with the Dow Jones Industrial Average is... more →
Peer mortgage

Should You Get a Peer-to-Peer Mortgage?

If you can’t get approved for a home loan from a bank, you might want to look into applying for a peer-to-peer mortgage. more →
Investment gifting is awesome.

4 Things To Know Before You Donate an Investment

While donations of any kind are appreciated, gifting investments benefits both the giver and the receiver. Here are four key things... more →
Are you wondering: What's the Relationship Between the Stock Market and Federal Debt?

What’s the Relationship Between the Stock Market and Federal Debt?

Wouldn’t it be wonderful if gains in the stock market could actually reduce U.S. government indebtedness? If that were true,... more →
Federal Student Loan Subsidies

Federal Student Loan Subsidies | Part of The Health Care Law?

As I drive through Any College Town, USA I notice an above average amount of urban sprawl, which has occured in the last 5 to 7 years. ... more →